Step back into the shadows of 1785, where mystery and murder haunt the sweltering streets of early Florida. The brutal Delany murder shocked a fledgling community—and over two centuries later, the case remains unsolved. Was it revenge, greed, or something more sinister? On this chilling stop, we’ll unearth the dark details of Florida’s oldest cold case—and let you decide what secrets still linger in the silence.

On this stop of the crawl, we delve into the twisted tale of W.D. Lindsey—a murder steeped in southern scandal, betrayal, and a bullet that still echoes through history. Was it cold-blooded revenge or justice served in the shadows? Grab a drink, lean in close, and uncover the chilling details of a crime that left a stain on the South—and a mystery in its wake.

In the heart of 1800s St. Augustine, a chilling murder sent shockwaves through the oldest city in America. Juan Carlos, once a trusted figure in the community, became the center of a dark tale filled with deceit, desperation, and deadly consequences. On this tour stop, we’ll peel back the layers of a crime that still haunts the cobblestone streets—and explore the lingering whispers of betrayal that history tried to forget.

In 1974, the brutal, broad-daylight murder of Athalia Lindsley stunned St. Augustine. A former model and political firebrand, Athalia was hacked to death just steps from her home—yet no one was ever convicted. Was it a crime of passion, revenge, or silence from those in power? This stop explores one of Florida’s most infamous unsolved murders, where the real terror may lie in what was left unsaid.

In the quiet charm of 1990s St. Augustine, the brutal murder of Amy Blount shattered the illusion of safety in Florida’s oldest city. What began as an ordinary night ended in unthinkable violence—and a community left reeling. On this stop, we revisit the harrowing details of the case that shook St. Augustine to its core, raising questions that still haunt the city to this day.