Travelers will begin at the historic Athenaeum, one of Indianapolis’s most distinctive landmarks and a former center of the city’s German-American community. As they admire the building’s grand architecture and learn about its cultural heritage, they will hear stories of unexplained footsteps, voices heard in empty rooms, doors moving on their own, and sightings of a mysterious woman wandering the halls. Guests will also discover the building’s connection to one of Indianapolis’s most notorious unsolved murder cases, adding another layer of intrigue to this historic site.

Travelers will visit the exterior of the iconic Murat Theatre, a spectacular former Shriners temple that has hosted generations of performances and events. While exploring its fascinating history and unique architecture, guests will hear reports of unexplained music echoing through empty spaces, shadowy figures moving through the theater, and a mysterious blue light seen drifting through the darkened halls. They will also learn about the famous portrait of longtime Murat leader Elias Jacoby, which has earned a reputation for appearing to change expression when no one is looking.

At this stop, travelers will delve into one of Indianapolis’s most disturbing unsolved mysteries. Standing near the site where Dr. Helen Knabe lived, guests will hear the tragic story of the respected physician who was found murdered in her apartment in 1911. As they learn about the baffling details of the case, including the missing murder weapon, they will explore the botched investigation, sensational theories, and unanswered questions that have kept the mystery alive for more than a century.

Travelers will conclude this portion of the tour at the site of the former Indianapolis Athletic Club, once one of the city's most prestigious private institutions. As they learn about the building’s history, they will hear the chilling story of the devastating 1992 fire that claimed the lives of two firefighters and one guest. Guests will discover reports from later residents describing heavy footsteps, the smell of smoke with no apparent source, shadowy figures, and even a mysterious voice warning people to "get out." Some believe the spirit of a firefighter may still linger here, continuing the rescue effort that ended in tragedy.